Coletta’s

Bar-b-q | Italian | Pizza
Memorable
One of the best
Save

It may seem odd to list an Italian-American restaurant in Memphis, Tennessee, as Roadfood, but there are at least two good reasons Coletta’s belongs. The first is barbecue pizza. In a city that loves barbecue-everything, including bologna and spaghetti, barbecue pizza has emphatic cultural imperative. And it makes taste-buds sense. A medium-thick crust pie with a glaze of melted mozzarella is topped not with Italian sauce and sausage or pepperoni, but with a moist hash of barbecued pork in zesty cinnabar pit sauce. No, the crust is not Neapolitan-elegant; nor is the barbecue going to win any blue ribbons; but this is a dish I’d recommend without equivocation to any adventurous omnivore.

Coletta’s also serves that other regional specialty, barbecue salad, which is like any ordinary dinner-house salad (iceberg lettuce, carrot shreds, tomatoes) but adorned with unsauced barbecue – the same savory pork as on the pizza. Dressing is the customer’s choice, and it makes all the difference. Italian vinaigrette nudges it in the direction of minimally-sauced eastern North Carolina ‘cue; 1000 Island or Russian is more like a mountain smoke house meal; ranch brings it close to that strange Alabama variety of sauce that is based on mayonnaise. Or, you can forgo salad dressing altogether and have it trimmed with barbecue sauce.

Coletta’s claims to be the oldest restaurant in Memphis (as do the Little Tea Shop and the Arcade). It does look like it’s been around a long time. The outside is forlorn and could use some decorative love. In the door, however, there isn’t a friendlier, warmer eatery in all of Memphis. Its staff of good ol’ girls are eager to help strangers as well as legions of regular customers for whom it has been a reliable source of good eats since grandma’s day.

Note: A second Coletta’s is located at 2850 Appling Rd. (901-383-1122)

What to Eat
Coletta’s, Barbecue Pizza (small)
Barbecue Pizza (small)
Must-Try
Culinary cognitive dissonance: BBQ pizza
Coletta’s, Barbecue Salad
Barbecue Salad
Must-Try
BBQ salad, loaded with pork
Coletta’s, Italian Sausage
Italian Sausage
Italian sausage, dressed with Italian 'gravy,' NOT barbecue sauce!
Directions and Hours
closed now
Sunday1pm - 9:30pm
Monday11am - 10pm
Tuesday11am - 10pm
Wednesday11am - 10pm
Thursday11am - 10pm
Friday11am - 11pm
Saturday12pm - 11pm
Information
Price
$$
Seasons
Open Year Round
Meals Served
Lunch, Dinner
Credit Cards Accepted
Yes
Alcohol Served
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Website

Other Nearby Restaurants

  • Central BBQ

    Memphis, Tennessee

    Central BBQ has done an amazing thing for nachos by adding its tender pulled pork, drizzling on some sweet BBQ sauce, and finishing with a touch of BBQ Shake.

  • Bozo’s Hot Pit Bar-B-Q

    Mason, Tennessee

    Since 1923, Bozo’s of Mason, Tennessee, has earned a reputation for hickory-smoked BBQ and outstanding homemade pies. An easy detour off Interstate 40.

  • Alcenia’s

    Memphis, Tennessee

    Alcenia’s is a warm, friendly Memphis, Tennessee, restaurant serving homey soul food meat-and-3 meals that end with glorious pies or bread pudding.

  • Little Tea Shop

    Memphis, Tennessee

    A vintage lunch room on old Cotton Row, Little Tea Shop is a Memphis experience all food lovers should have, from pot likker to fudge-topped frozen pecan balls.

  • Gus’s World Famous Hot and Spicy Chicken

    Memphis, Tennessee

    Memphis glory: Gus’s fried chicken is cased in an envelope of crust with vigorous crunch, radiating the ecstatic flavor combination of chicken fat and pepper.

  • Jones Bar-B-Q Diner

    Marianna, Arkansas

    Jones has a sign in the parking lot that says open since 1964, but owner James Jones told us goes back 150 years. Superb Arkansas BBQ!