Shortstop Deli

Grocery Store | Pizza | Sandwich Shop
legendary
Worth driving from anywhere!
Save

More of a big convenience store than a sit-down eatery, the Shortstop Deli features shelves of snack foods, countless varieties of coffee, and a counter where you order for what is formally known as a Hot Truck Pizza Sub. There are no tables and chairs, just some concrete benches outside the front window where it is possible to bring your wrapped sandwich and your cup of soda and dine al fresco.

The pizza subs are fantastic. Made on loaves of Ithaca Bakery French bread, they range from the basic PMP (Poor Man’s Pizza), which is nothing but bread, sauce, and cheese, to the extravaganza known as a Suicide (garlic, sauce, mushrooms, sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella). Each one is piled with its ingredients, then baked open-face until the bread is shatteringly crisp, the cheese bubbles, and the meats sizzle.

These sandwiches, originally served by Bob Petrillose from Johnny’s Pizza Truck starting in 1960, have inspired a language all their own. For example, a Triple Sui, Hot and Heavy, G and G translates as a full Suicide with three extra homemade meatballs, a sprinkle of red pepper, extra garlic, mayonnaise, and lettuce. (G and G = grease and garden, i.e. mayo & lettuce.) An Indy includes link sausage, pepperoni, onion, sauce, and cheese, hot and heavy. A Flaming Turkey Bone Includes chicken breast, tomato sauce, cheese, onions, extra hot and heavy, plus “spontaneous combustion” (double-X hot sauce).

Not only is there a whole dictionary of terms for ordering these sandwiches. Their source itself is so much a part of Ithaca’s culinary culture that regular customers refer to what’s served here not as “Pizza Subs” or “Hot Truck Sandwiches” but simply as “Hot Truck,” as in Let’s go get some Hot Truck or Did you enjoy your Hot Truck? When you think about it, that’s about the highest compliment a Roadfoodie can pay, to make the name of a restaurant into a proper noun for its cuisine.

What to Eat
Shortstop Deli, Suicide Pizza Sub
Suicide Pizza Sub
Must-Try
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, sauce, cheese
Directions and Hours
closed now
Sunday12 am -
MondayCLOSED
TuesdayCLOSED
WednesdayCLOSED
ThursdayCLOSED
FridayCLOSED
SaturdayCLOSED
Information
Price
$
Seasons
Open Year Round
Meals Served
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
Credit Cards Accepted
No
Alcohol Served
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Website

Other Nearby Restaurants

  • Mother’s Cupboard

    Syracuse, New York

    Mother’s Cupboard is a tiny Syracuse diner that serves big omelets and pancakes, heavyweight biscuits and gravy, and a six-pound frittata.

  • Laura’s Luncheonette

    Binghamton, New York

    Laura’s Luncheonette is home to hearty breakfast basics like fluffy blueberry muffins crisped on the griddle, super thin bacon, and… chocolate cake.

  • Nickel’s Pit BBQ

    Watkins Glen, New York

    Nickel’s Pit BBQ is known for its Pig Wing: a St. Louis-style rib that’s smoked 4 hours, then crisped in the fryer. Beer is local, as is much of the provender.

  • Doug’s Fish Fry

    Cortland, New York

    Doug’s fish sandwich is a New York best: chunky, moist white fish encased in a sandy crust with just the right amount of crunch. Dessert: excellent custard.

  • Phil’s Chicken House

    Endicott, New York

    Phil’s is a source for a Cornell chicken dinner built around a bird that’s slow cooked and relentlessly basted until glazed gold and dripping juice.

  • Apple Dumpling Cafe

    Binghamton, New York

    Apple Dumpling pancakes come filled with farm fresh fruit, topped with locally produced maple syrup. And don’t forget the freshly made donuts.