Skip to content

Roadfood

Your Guide to Authentic Regional Eats

  • Restaurants Near Me
  • Reviews
  • Restaurant Type
  • States
  • Guides
  • Forums
  • About Roadfood
  • Sign In / Out
Roadfood on Instagram Roadfood on Facebook Roadfood on Twitter
  • Roadfood on Instagram Roadfood on Facebook Roadfood on Twitter
    • reviews
    • guides
    • recipes
    • forums
    • about
  • Restaurant Type
  • State
  • Restaurants Near Me

Home › Forums › Miscellaneous Forums › Miscellaneous – Food Related › Why Jews eat Chinese Food on Christmas

This topic contains 14 replies, has 0 voices, and was last updated by CNW CNW 14 years, 10 months ago.

Author
Posts
  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594064
    EdSails
    EdSails
    Member

    Apparently either there are a lot of Jews or a lot of Chinese around Bass lake, because it took over an hour for them to fill our order. Or Won Ton soup, Spareribs, Kung Pao  Shrimp, Orange Peel Beef………..a traditional Jewish Chrismas Eve dinner. Of course we did have ham, smoked turkey (thank you Traeger) and stuffing, jello mold, all the standards. 

     

     

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594113
    Walleye
    Walleye
    Member

    Two weeks ago we saw A Christmas Story: The Musical.  When the Parker family walks into to the Chinese restaurant on Christmas the father waves to the side and says to Mrs. Parker “there is the Swartz (or Schwartz) family.”

    Schwartz was one of the characters in the film — Ralphie’s friend. Interestingly, Scott Schwartz played Ralphie’s friend Flick.

    But Ralphie had no reaction like he would have if it had been his friend and his family.  And his friend did not appear in the musical, so it had to have just been a joke about Jews going to Chinese restaurants on Christmas. 

    The musical? Actually, Ralphie told his mother earlier in the film that he’d learned a swear word from Schwartz. With that his mother called Schwartz’s mother who was furious with her son and began screaming at him, so I guess Ralphie and Schwartz were no longer pals.

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594114
    mlm
    mlm
    Member

    Actually, I read that the Mother’s shocked and giggly response to the duck and said’s decapitation was real. Apparently, the actress had not been told what to expect.  One of my favorite parts of the movie and probably authentic to the times since Chinese food was not as mainstream, as yet, in the 30s and 40s. Even now, that type of presentation would get a reaction from me, since I’m not particularly sophisicated culinarily.

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594119
    plb
    plb
    Member

    Two weeks ago we saw A Christmas Story: The Musical.  When the Parker family walks into to the Chinese restaurant on Christmas the father waves to the side and says to Mrs. Parker “there is the Swartz (or Schwartz) family.”

    Schwartz was one of the characters in the film — Ralphie’s friend. Interestingly, Scott Schwartz played Ralphie’s friend Flick.

    But Ralphie had no reaction like he would have if it had been his friend and his family.  And his friend did not appear in the musical, so it had to have just been a joke about Jews going to Chinese restaurants on Christmas. 

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594122
    Mar-52
    Mar-52
    Member

    But My Friend Flicka was a horse.

     

    (Had to)

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594124
    Walleye
    Walleye
    Member

    Two weeks ago we saw A Christmas Story: The Musical.  When the Parker family walks into to the Chinese restaurant on Christmas the father waves to the side and says to Mrs. Parker “there is the Swartz family.”

    Schwartz was one of the characters in the film — Ralphie’s friend. Interestingly, Scott Schwartz played Ralphie’s friend Flick.

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594126
    plb
    plb
    Member

    Two weeks ago we saw A Christmas Story: The Musical.� When the Parker family�walks into�to the Chinese restaurant on Christmas the father waves to the side and says to Mrs. Parker "there is the Swartz family."

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594132
    Mar-52
    Mar-52
    Member

    A bowl of Pho sounds so good!

     

    We had tamales.  I ran around town yesterday until I found a place that wasn’t sold out.

     

    Sharon isn’t a fan of Chinese food so we’ll probably (if we venture out) go to Dinah’s for their traditional Christmas Dinner which is either a turkey dinner or a ham dinner… just like at home.

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594151
    CNW
    CNW
    Member

    Buddy, the best Chinese in town is at Bo Lings on the Plaza or the Dragon Inn in downtown OP. I was kind of stuffed up last night so this Catholic boy had a bowl of Pho.

     

    CNW

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594156
    BuddyRoadhouse
    BuddyRoadhouse
    Member

    Just returned home from our Jewish Christmas Eve Dinner at China Palace in Overland Park (Lenexa?), KS.  We ate light following a big lunch at KC’s current ‘Que hot spot, SLAP’S BBQ.  A good time was had by all, including two goyim and one recent convert.

     

    Merry Christmas to all my Roadfood friends of the Christian persuasion!

     

    Buddy

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594159
    EdSails
    EdSails
    Member

    So guess what we had for Christmas Eve Dinner?

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594167
    Mar-52
    Mar-52
    Member

    Only places open and no dairy with the meat being served.

     

    Pork doesn’t count!

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594182
    MetroplexJim
    MetroplexJim
    Member

    That was an interesting article, but I’m not so sure that the Jews/Chinese “bonded” in their “otherness”.  Like so many other modern social commentators the author sees the past through lenses ground in their relatively recent ‘higher education’. 

     

    In what is rare for me I’m going to agree with Senator Schumer’s observation that “Chinese restaurants were the only places open”; Occam’s Razor in action![;)]

     

     

  • June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2594187
    CNW
    CNW
    Member

    This story from The Atlantic explains the probable origins.

     

    http://www.msn.com/en-us/foodanddrink/foodnews/why-american-jews-eat-chinese-food-on-christmas/ar-BBh9y3i?ocid=iehp http://www.msn.com/en-us/foodanddrink/foodnews/why-american-jews-eat-chinese-food-on-christmas/ar-BBh9y3i?ocid=iehp

     

    Growing up in Kansas City the Jewish population was small and lived in a different part of town do the first time I ever heard of this was when I went to college. When I was in the Navy a couple of years later the officer in charge of the mess was Jewish and told the cooks that Jews were entitled to their traditional Christmas Dinner just like Christians were. So, there was the traditional Ham and Turkey with all the sides and a selection of Chinese dishes for Christmas Dinner.

     

    CNW

  • December 26, 2014 at 1:22 pm #895933
    CNW
    CNW
    Member

    Why Jews eat Chinese Food on Christmas

  • Author
    Posts

    You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

    FORUM SEARCH

    Log In
    Register

    Forums

    • Beverage Forum
    • Breakfast Forum
    • Desserts Forum
    • Lunch & Dinner Forums
    • Miscellaneous Forums
    • Regional Forums
    • Restaurant Professionals Forum
    • Roadfood News & Information Forums
    • Side Dishes Forum
    • Snacks & Candy Forum

    Forum Statistics

    Registered Users
    26,998
    Forums
    41
    Topics
    51,038
    Replies
    686,465
    Topic Tags
    1,978
    • Most popular topics
    • Topics with no replies
    • Topics with most replies
    • Latest topics
    • Topics Freshness
      • home
      • reviews
      • forums
      • about
      • privacy policy
      • your california privacy rights
      • sign in / out
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter!

    Proudly powered by WordPress