Skip to content

Roadfood

Your Guide to Authentic Regional Eats

  • Restaurants Near Me
  • Reviews
  • Restaurant Type
  • States
  • Guides
  • Forums
  • About Roadfood
  • Sign In / Out
Roadfood on Instagram Roadfood on Facebook Roadfood on Twitter
  • Roadfood on Instagram Roadfood on Facebook Roadfood on Twitter
    • reviews
    • guides
    • recipes
    • forums
    • about
  • Restaurant Type
  • State
  • Restaurants Near Me

Home › Forums › Miscellaneous Forums › Miscellaneous – Food Related › San Francisco American: Mel’s Diner vs Max’s Diner

This topic contains 6 replies, has 0 voices, and was last updated by peppertree peppertree 17 years, 5 months ago.

Author
Posts
  • September 1, 2003 at 6:28 pm #2333054
    LizzieR
    LizzieR
    Member

    Thanks, Peppertree. We’ll be sure to try Max’s the next time we’re in San Francisco.

  • September 1, 2003 at 6:28 pm #2333055
    peppertree
    peppertree
    Member

    Max’s is almost across the street from the Moscone Center. It is in the Mission Districe, I think on fourth street.

    The menu is very similar to Mel’s. I was curious as to which one is favored by people on this board.

  • September 1, 2003 at 6:28 pm #2333056
    LizzieR
    LizzieR
    Member

    When in San Francisco we always go to Mel’s. Sorry, never heard of Max. Where is it? Please describe food and atmosphere. Thanks.

  • September 1, 2003 at 6:28 pm #2333057
    VibrationGuy
    VibrationGuy
    Member

    I *heart* all the Max’s outposts. They "get" being customer-centric, providing good value and what it takes to earn repeat business.

    Eric, Suddenly Hungry For A Reuben Of Indelicate Size

  • September 1, 2003 at 6:28 pm #2333058
    St. Louis Browns fan
    St. Louis Browns fan
    Member

    I never made it to Max’s , but I sure enjoyed Mel’s during a trip to S.F. Breakfast (turkey hash) was wonderful, and prices are quite reasonable by California standards.

  • September 1, 2003 at 6:28 pm #2333059
    peppertree
    peppertree
    Member

    Well, who is better? Mel’s or Max’s. They are both serving the essence of mid-20th century American food.

    I went to Max’s on my last trip and this month I visited Mel’s. How to compare? The food at both is great. Just what I like. What do you think?

    For fun, I want to print Max’s Laws sm from the back of their menu:

    Max’s Laws sm

    1. This restaurant is run for the enjoyment and pleasure of our customers, not the convenience of the staff or the owners.

    2. You get a free round of drinks if anyone on our staff comes up and says, "Is everything all right?" When we ask questions, they’ll be good ones.

    3. You must get your mustard and ketchup before your burger, snadwich or fries.

    4. We hate soggy fries. If yours aren’t crisp, the way you like them-send them back-maybe the kitchen will get the message.

    5. Corned beef and pastrami are good because they contain some fat; however, with today’s dietary consciousness, our corned beef and pastrami are now extra lean. So ask for a little fat for that traditional taste. If you want something with no fat, how about our turkey or turkey pastrami.

    6. The turkey is always fresh. Period.

    7. Our iced tea is table brewed. Just pour it over a big glass of ice.

    8. You’ll love our breads and pastries. They’re made fresh daily in Max’s Bakery and Kitchen.

    9. Warning: We bake our own sourdough crusty as can be. If you like soft bread, eat the middle.

    10. Our ice cream sauces are a point of pride. They’re made in New York by a certified chocoholic who refuses therapy. They are simply tje best in the country. And we don’t boast idly.

    11. We bring ice cream sauces from New York City and mustards from Oregon. Eat here. Save the airfare.

    12. This is a bad place for a diet and a good place for a diet.

    13. Our desserts are excessive because nothing succeeds like excess. We encourage sharing if you’re not super hungry.

    14. Substitutions are okay by us; don’t be bashful, you’ve got a mouth, use it.

    15. We use cholesterol-free oil for frying and sauteing; anything can be grilled fat-free!

    16. If you are a single diner and are greeted with the expression, "Just one?." dinner is on us.

    17. We agree that the customer is always right. If there is a problem with your food or service, call for the manager-we’ll fix it in a flash. But, if you finish your plate-it couldn’t have been all that bad! Now, could it?

    18. If, upon presentation of your check, your server says, "Do you want change?" Forget about the tip!

  • September 12, 2003 at 8:53 pm #133041
    peppertree
    peppertree
    Member

    San Francisco American: Mel’s Diner vs Max’s Diner

  • Author
    Posts

    You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

    FORUM SEARCH

    Log In
    Register

    Forums

    • Beverage Forum
    • Breakfast Forum
    • Desserts Forum
    • Lunch & Dinner Forums
    • Miscellaneous Forums
    • Regional Forums
    • Restaurant Professionals Forum
    • Roadfood News & Information Forums
    • Side Dishes Forum
    • Snacks & Candy Forum

    Forum Statistics

    Registered Users
    24,529
    Forums
    41
    Topics
    51,038
    Replies
    686,465
    Topic Tags
    1,978
    • Most popular topics
    • Topics with no replies
    • Topics with most replies
    • Latest topics
    • Topics Freshness
      • home
      • reviews
      • forums
      • about
      • privacy policy
      • your california privacy rights
      • sign in / out
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter!

    Proudly powered by WordPress