This year we are down to 4 girls, each of whom could be a star.
One final word..
Just saw this…
Disney and David Cook…….
Went to the bathroom during the ZZ Top thing and missed all of it! Darn. I thought it was rather smarmy and mean when what’s his name announced the winner and said, "And the winner, BY 12 MILLION VOTES, is…….." Who the hell wants to know that they lost by 12 million votes? I thought that comment was unnecessary and cruel. But then, I’m an unusually sensitive old bastard.
Great performance by all 12. I too loved seeing Cook with ZZ Top, about my all time favorite band.
This year was good – I think the best all around vocalist and performer won.
I was hoping that Syesha would have beaten out Archie…
I think her voice is wonderful…..
Well, it’s all over for this year. Tha Cookster won it all. And yes, that ZZ thing was neat.
How about Syesha and Donna Summers!
And, I hope David’s bro does OK!
I come out of this as a fan Syesha, and Jason.
Me three.. I bet he was thrilled as can be…..
Very touching with his ill brother up thre….
Yes, at least somebodies music which I would buy won American Idol tonight. Loved the ZZ Top set he did.
Yep Davis is gonna win it and I hope it is Cook.
I’d bet anything David wins. [;)] pb
Yoh, dude, man, listen up…here’s the thing.
While Archuleta is good in a way, his voice just isn’t "big enough" for my tastes. Especially covering the Neil Diamond stuff, just way to thin and breathy. He can’t "drive it home" if you know what I mean.
David Cook may be the only one left with a "rock star presence" but, last week, when he had the whole world of rock to pick from, he pretty much sucked. Talk about poor song choices! Meanwhile, Archuleta, with hardly a "rock star presence" stole the show. Syesha has a great future, perhaps on Broadway, but I doubt she can win this thing. It’ll come down to the 2 Davids and, since the fans have the vote, it just depends on which is most popular. Anyone who thinks these 3 have no talent is no judge of talent. jmho, pb
IMHO David Cook is the only one with a rock star presence. Simon criticized him one night for coming off as arrogant or something, um& ever watched Bono Simon? Front men are supposed to arrogant and vain. The other David looks to be damaged goods I m afraid, he d fit right in at the Culkin family dinner table.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.