Safe Harbor Restaurant

Sandwich Shop | Seafood
Memorable
One of the best
Save

To get to Safe Harbor, you need to drive around a corner and to the end of 2nd Avenue. If you get to the water and are among a group of empty boat trailers, you’ve found it — a little building right on the Waterway

We arrive just before 5. The place is beginning to fill up. All around are signs about not saving tables and making sure you keep aisles clear, so I’m sure it’s a madhouse during busier hours.

The menu and specials sign stops us at the front, and we’re entranced with all the fresh-from-the-water options. Specials are particularly alluring, because we can see the just-caught red fish glistening in the ice-packed case behind it. Options for fried, blackened, and grilled come with just about any kind of fish you order.

We came for shrimp — we are in Florida, after all; and Mayport shrimp are famous. We get ours in a two-item basket that contains both blackened shrimp and fried calamari. I could devour two full baskets of just the shrimp. The plump, perfectly cooked pink crustaceans are more spicy than sweet. The calamari are chewy and fresh, lightly battered and camouflaged among French fries that are the same color.

Red fish in fish tacos is blackened with a kick, nicely balancing the sweetness of the fish along with mango salsa. A dollop of lime crema is all it needs.

The only thing that doesn’t wow us is the crab dip, served with simple crackers. It is overwhelmed with mayo.

The market operated for 25 years as a wholesale distribution company before opening its restaurants in Mayport and Jacksonville Beach.

When we leave, the place has completely filled up, with more trickling in to try and beat the early 6 PM closing time.

What to Eat
Safe Harbor Restaurant, 2-Way Captain Walters Combo
2-Way Captain Walters Combo
Must-Try
A two-way Captain Walters combo: blackened shrimp & calamari
Safe Harbor Restaurant, Blackened Red Fish Tacos
Blackened Red Fish Tacos
Must-Try
Mango salsa atop freshly-caught, blackened red fish
Safe Harbor Restaurant, Blackened Shrimp
Blackened Shrimp
Must-Try
Best dish: blackened shrimp
Safe Harbor Restaurant, Calamari
Calamari
Must-Try
Calamari is stretchy with crunch, served with corn-dotted hushpuppies.
Safe Harbor Restaurant, Crab Dip
Crab Dip
Crab dip is served with buttery crackers.
Directions and Hours
closed now
Sunday10:30am - 9pm
Monday10:30am - 9pm
Tuesday10:30am - 9pm
Wednesday10:30am - 9pm
Thursday10:30am - 9pm
Friday10:30am - 9pm
Saturday10:30am - 9pm
Information
Price
$$
Seasons
Open Year Round
Meals Served
Lunch, Dinner
Credit Cards Accepted
Yes
Alcohol Served
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Website

Other Nearby Restaurants

  • Whitey’s Fish Camp

    Fleming Island, Florida

    Great catfish puts Whitey’s on the Florida best-eats map. They’re caught wild, fried whole to perfection, and brought to the table until you’ve had your fill.

  • The Floridian

    St. Augustine, Florida

    Southern food meets sustainable ingredients at The Floridian, home of pickled pepper shrimp, biscuits with pork belly, & fried chicken with hot-sauce honey.

  • La Herencia Cafe

    St. Augustine, Florida

    Sit outside and observe the oldest street in America while you enjoy a Media Noche sandwich at La Herencia Cafe of St. Augustine.

  • Good Dough

    Jacksonville, Florida

    Good Dough is a Jacksonville neighborhood bakery that sets a high bar with fried chicken doughwiches and torched crème brûlée doughnuts.

  • Beach Road Chicken Dinners

    Jacksonville, Florida

    Jacksonville’s vintage southern fried chicken house, dating back to 1939, Beach Road serves chicken all ways along with a wide variety of worthy side dishes.

  • O’Steen’s Restaurant

    St. Augustine, Florida

    St. Augustine’s best shrimp are served at O’Steen’s. Also unique local red Minorcan clam chowder and fine Southern-style side dishes. Popular & always crowded.