Russell’s Pizza

Italian | Pizza
good
Worth a return
Michael Stern | July 06, 2018
Save

If you are looking for authentic Italian pizza, go somewhere else. But if you like robust Italian-American pizza and exuberant sub sandwiches, put Russell’s on your to-eat list any time you are near Wagener, South Carolina. It’s a cozy, side-street, small-town shop with minimal amenities (plastic utensils, paper dishware, unupholstered seating) and a short menu of well-crafted dishes guaranteed to vanquish the most rapacious appetite.

Pizza has a thin crust that puffs up and deliciously blisters all around the circumference, crisp enough to stay level to the very point of a topping-laden slice. Ingredients are not artisan, but they are good quality and mix well with each other. I’ve yet to try a simple cheese pizza — suspect it would be boring — but a works pie with all kinds of different meats, veggies, and just the right amount of cheese (not too gloppy) is a can’t-stop-eating delight.

An item listed on the menu as an “Original Wedge” bears little resemblance to what’s found in pizzerias of Westchester County, New York (where wedge is the regionally specific term for a hero sandwich). It’s more like an Italian-flavored puffy taco or stuffed pizza: a broad, folded over round of bread that exactly straddles the line between bendable and breakable. Inside is a cornucopia of ingredients: pepperoni, sausage, chicken, mozzarella, cheddar, and ranch-dressed lettuce. It’s a neat package. At first bite, it becomes a mess … albeit a yummy one.

Yet to be sampled: lasagna billed as homemade, a loaded baked potato, burgers, and wings.

There are two other locations of Russell’s Pizza: 571 Main St. in Blackville (803-284-3001); and 13031 Main St. in Williston (803-266-7722).

Thanks to Sophie Plowright for tipping us off.

What to Eat
Russell’s Pizza, Works Pizza
Works Pizza
Must-Try
Works pizza, individually sized
Russell’s Pizza, Original Wedge
Original Wedge
Must-Try
Salad, sandwich, enchilada, pita pocket: The Original Wedge is some of each
Russell’s Pizza, Stromboli
Stromboli
Must-Try
Stromboli, aka calzone, is a pocket pizza. Or is it a pizza pocket?
Directions and Hours
Information
Seasons
Open Year Round
Meals Served
Lunch, Dinner
Credit Cards Accepted
Yes
Alcohol Served
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Website

Other Nearby Restaurants

  • Restaurante Las Palmas

    Aiken, South Carolina

    A broad menu of scrupulously cooked-to-order Mexican food at reasonable prices in the most informal surroundings makes Restaurante Las Palmas a Roadfood prize.

  • Root Cellar

    Lexington, South Carolina

    Downhome southern food with an uptown twist makes the Root Cellar a fun Lexington, South Carolina, restaurant for culinary traditionalists & adventurers alike.

  • Dukes

    Aiken, South Carolina

    Dukes is an Aiken, South Carolina all-you-can-eat BBQ buffet, featuring pulled pork plus terrific fried chicken and a couple dozen exemplary side dishes.

  • Humanitree House

    Augusta, Georgia

    Humanitree’s vegan menu includes sandwiches as well as cold-pressed juices & smoothies with superfood add-ins. Its vibe is laid-back, artistic, counter-culture.

  • Freeman’s Bar-B-Q

    Beech Island, South Carolina

    A third-generation BBQ serving superb South Carolina-style ‘cue, Freeman’s has ribs, chopped or sliced pork, and chicken — all with wickedly flavorful sauce.

  • Feel Good Food Truck

    Aiken, South Carolina

    Feel Good Food Truck is a high-spirited enterprise serving spectacular hamburgers, outlandish grilled cheese and beer-battered French fries. Seats outside & in.