Jersey Bagels

Bakery | Sandwich Shop
good
Worth a return
Michael Stern | December 02, 2018
Save

Consider the name of this restaurant. I cannot justify it as an authentic taste of Myrtle Beach, South Carolina; but if you are in Myrtle Beach and crave bagels, it’s a place you will be happy to know about.

Boiled and baked on premises, they’re extra large, dense and chewy the way good bagels ought to be. I love gnawing them as is, and while they are fine for sandwiches, their massive oomph can overwhelm (and squish) whatever ingredients they hold.

Given that it’s Jersey Bagels, the must-eat item is a pork roll sandwich. New Jersey’s unofficial state meat pairs so well with egg and cheese, but I do think the combo works better on a softer, lighter hard roll (which is available here) than on one of the assertive bagels. Even though ingredients tend to slither out as you eat it, the combination of flavors — including the good flavor of the fresh bagel — is a winning one.

The sandwich menu is immense, featuring not only every possible thing you can put in a bagel, from butter & jelly or Nutella to a full-house tuna melt, but also a roster of hot and cold sub sandwiches as well as a Philly cheese steak on an Amoroso roll. Sandwiches are huge and beautifully constructed.

As for ambience, it’s New Jersey all the way: walls plastered with Garden State license plates, pictures of local heros, odes to the New York Giants, and that favorite Mid-Atlantic sandwich-shop decor, one-dollar bills.

What to Eat
Jersey Bagels, Pork Roll Sandwich
Pork Roll Sandwich
Pork roll, egg & cheese: New Jersey on a bagel
Jersey Bagels, Reuben
Reuben
Big, thick, well-balanced Reuben on hearty rye
Jersey Bagels, Italian Sub
Italian Sub
Piled-high Italian sub
Directions and Hours
closed now
Sunday8am - 1pm
Monday7:30am - 3pm
Tuesday7:30am - 3pm
Wednesday7:30am - 3pm
Thursday7:30am - 3pm
Friday7:30am - 3pm
Saturday8am - 3pm
Information
Price
$
Seasons
Open Year Round
Meals Served
Breakfast, Lunch
Credit Cards Accepted
Yes
Alcohol Served
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Website

Other Nearby Restaurants

  • Blueberry’s Grill

    Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

    Myrtle Beach’s best breakfast is a full coffee shop repertoire, including inventive variations of southern favorites. Don’t miss the corned beef hash!

  • Pulaski Deli

    Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

    Pulaski Deli is a Myrtle Beach anomaly: homelike, old-world food in a quiet, personable market. The Polish Sampler plate gets you some of everything.

  • Big Mike’s Soul Food

    Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

    Savvy Myrtle Beach locals know and love Big Mike’s. If you are a visitor in search of authentic soul food and genuine hospitality, it’s a treasure to remember.

  • Calabash Seafood Hut

    Calabash, North Carolina

    A small, humble dining hut serving excellent examples of the fried seafood for which the town of Calabash is world-famous. Very popular: expect to wait.

  • Hotdog

    Calabash, North Carolina

    The word “artisan” barely does justice to the extraordinary hot dogs, house-baked buns, and pies that make this inexpensive Calabash storefront a Roadfood treasure.

  • Simply Southern Smokehouse

    Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

    Simply Southern Smokehouse lives up to its name, offering a grand buffet of regional specialties including BBQ, chicken bog, and downhome desserts.