Island House Restaurant

Review by: Michael Stern

Beautiful Food, Beautiful Place

How do you like your oysters? On the half shell? Steamed? Fried? Oysters Rockefeller (with spinach and Pernod)? Oysters Parramore (topped with lump crab and melted cheese)? The Island House Restaurant has all that and much, much more. In this big, handsome place with its achingly beautiful view of the Eastern Shore’s Barrier Islands and Watchapreague Harbor, seafood satisfaction is guaranteed.

Hors D’oeuvre

Several appetizers cry for attention. Island House cooks marinate calamari in buttermilk, bread it and fry it crisp and serve it with aioli for dipping. The dip pairs perfectly with the calamari’s sweet, tender meat. Taste buds eager to be caressed in the softest possible way will enjoy hot crab dip judiciously spiced with Old Bay. If you’re not getting flounder for an entree, start with flounder fingers, which the kitchen fries crisp and serves with spicy sriracha sauce. Did you know that Wachapreague is the flounder fishing capital of the world?

Oysters Parramore belong at the start of any meal. The menu bills them as a “healthy option,” thanks to all the crab meat piled in. But all that cheese on top, melting into the crab and the salty seaside oysters below, makes makes me question their nutritional virtue. In other words, they’re wonderful.

No-Frills Local

Provender is as local as it gets. The kitchen secures crab meat, seaside oysters, and flounder from sources that are a bicycle ride away. Many of the restaurant’s best dishes make the most of those groceries by doing the least to them.

Order the broiled seafood medley and get scallops, flounder, and a crab cake all simply broiled: no fuss, no folderol. Fresh Atlantic scallops come either broiled or fried. When you select the “fisherman’s favorite” of one crab cake and a flounder fillet, you may choose to have them broiled or fried. Again, seafood satisfaction needs nothing elaborate.

Crab Fancies

On the other hand, the Island House Kitchen does enjoy a few creative flights of culinary fancy in which crab meat stars. Hushpuppies here transform into crab hushpuppies. You can get a “Backfin burger” topped with bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and fresh backfin crab meat. You even can have a crab quesadilla.

Smith Island Cake

For dessert, be sure to fork into a slice of the official state dessert of Maryland, Smith Island Cake. The multi-layered tour de force gets its name from Smith Island in the Chesapeake Bay on the other side of the Eastern Shore.

What To Eat

Smith Island Cake


Baked Oysters


Island House Restaurant Recipes


What do you think of Island House Restaurant?

One Response to “Island House Restaurant”

Chris Kozel

June 18th, 2022

The ‘get directions’ link for Island House Restaurant does not link to the right locations. It takes you to Staten Island instead.


Nearby Restaurants

Exmore Diner

Exmore, VA

Metompkin Seafood | Best Casual Eastern Shore Seafood

Mappsville, VA

Sting Ray’s | Best Eastern Shore Seafood, at Chez Exxon

Cape Charles, VA

Megallon’s Gourmet BBQ

Norfolk, VA

Bear Creek Open Pit BBQ

Callaway, MD

Article’s & Guides Tagged Bear Creek Open Pit BBQ


Connect with us #Roadfood