FireFly

New American | Southern Comfort
excellent
Worth a detour
Michael Stern | October 16, 2019
Save

The difference between a cook and a chef? Chefs cook what they want you to eat; cooks cook what you want to eat. At FireFly, dining is all about the chef. It bills itself as a “chef-driven restaurant”; and the staff elucidates with an introduction that informs customers in no uncertain terms that they will be eating what the chef wants them to eat. Substitutions and alterations are not welcome.

I’ll admit, my hackles rise at the thought of a cuisinier so controlling; but once FireFly food starts coming, it is easy to forgive the ego. I am happy to put myself in this chef’s hands.

What chef Russ Ferstle excels at is harmony: multiple ingredients brought together in swirling chords of flavor. Shrimp and grits includes not only buff shrimp and creamy grits but also smoked cheddar cheese and smoky tomato butter. It’s big and brassy and deeply satisfying. Bacon-crab beignets, which are like crab cakes but fluffier and porkier, attain excellence when dredged in the skillet full of gouda fondue that comes alongside them. I’m not sure what to think of the inventive roasted cauliflower wedge, which is like an iceberg wedge — complete with bacon, marvelous blue cheese, and tomatoes plus crisp pecans — but with a honking huge hunk of firm roasted cauliflower instead of lettuce. The familiar wedge flavors are there, but it’s warm instead of cool and chewy instead of crisp. Fascinating.

Not everything is so complicated. Fried chicken is an expertly fried classic with the crispest possible crust and juice-dripping meat within (even the breast). It’s a modest-tempered version with only minimal seasoning — more dignified than flashy. It is accompanied by fine mashed potatoes and gravy and a skilletful of extraordinarily porky collard greens.

Key lime cake — not pie — is a signature dessert. It is extremely fluffy, so tender that it easily can be overwhelmed if you get too much of its abundant cream cheese frosting on your forkful. It is an imbalance cheerfully remedied by all the fresh berries and fruit compote spread across its plate.

What to Eat
FireFly, Fried Chicken
Fried Chicken
Must-Try
Fried chicken, mashed potatoes with gravy, hamhock-rich collards
FireFly, Shrimp & Grits
Shrimp & Grits
Must-Try
Shrimp, grits, smoked cheddar & smoky tomato butter
FireFly, Cauliflower Wedge
Cauliflower Wedge
Must-Try
Roasted cauliflower wedge with abundant bleu cheese
FireFly, Bacon-Crab Beignets
Bacon-Crab Beignets
Must-Try
Fried chicken, mashed potatoes with gravy, hamhock-rich collards
FireFly, Key Lime Cake
Key Lime Cake
Must-Try
Key lime cake is thick with cream cheese frosting.
FireFly, Blood Orange Mimosa
Blood Orange Mimosa
Must-Try
Blood orange mimosa
Directions and Hours
closed now
Sunday6pm - 10pm
Monday6pm - 10pm
Tuesday6pm - 10pm
Wednesday6pm - 10pm
Thursday6pm - 10pm
Friday6pm - 10pm
Saturday6pm - 10pm
Information
Price
$
Seasons
Open Year Round
Meals Served
Lunch, Dinner
Credit Cards Accepted
Yes
Alcohol Served
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Website

Other Nearby Restaurants

  • Hogfish Bar & Grill

    Stock Island, Florida

    Hogfish Bar & Grill offers a happy, casual, tropical-themed taste of Florida-Keys life, including superb local seafood and masterfully mixed cocktails.

  • Hurricane Hole

    Key West, Florida

    Utterly fresh seafood & clever cocktails served under sun by the water on a colorful marina make Hurricane Hole a dreamy destination at the edge of Key West.

  • Fisherman’s Cafe

    Key West, Florida

    At the Key West seaport, Fisherman’s Cafe is a casual walk-up eatery serving Conch eats to go or to enjoy at al fresco tables. Open early for breakfast.

  • Blue Heaven

    Key West, Florida

    House motto: “Blue Heaven: you don’t have to die to get there.” The outdoor terrace is a magical place for breakfast (or lunch or supper) on Key West.

  • La Petite Grignote

    Key West, Florida

    A more secluded version of Key West’s fine French bakery serves the best pastries in town. Egg breakfasts, bread, coffee & smoothies all are grand.

  • Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Pie Shoppe

    Key West, Florida

    The Key Lime Pie Nexus of the Universe, Kermit’s, at the seaport, invented Frozen Key lime pie on a stick enrobed in chocolate: sweet-tooth nirvana.