Since I haven’t lived there in many years, all I can say for the not to be missed are two bakeries: Dewey’s at Thruway Shopping Center and Winkler’s in Old Salem. Dewey’s is known for Moravian Sugar Cake and Winkler’s for their hearth baked bread. We used to actually call Winkler’s and reserve loaves of bread because the demand was so high and they usually ran out before closing.
If you have to make only one stop, do it at Winkler’s; I think they have sugar cake as well there. While in Old Salem, you can try the Salem Tavern just down the street. Both are on Main St.