@Joerogo- Hawley isnt a food persons paradise….I would probably recommend Joe and Lorenzos for a pizza on Main St. Mikes pizza out route 590 used to be alright..havent been in years though.
Maybe try out The Settlers Inn. I havent been there to eat in years…its probably been turned over many times since Ive been in there. My grandparents used to own the place though. My grandma and grandpa would do all the cooking and my mom and 2 aunts would clean/run the place etc. This was back in the 60s. Its more upscale from what their website looks like but its definitely a cool place to check out. We rarely ever ate out whenever I was back there. Between my grandparents, aunts/uncles etc there was always a fantastic home cooked meal.