All those recommendations are good and I’ve posted on several other locations as well. If you do a search on "Williamsburg" you should find a lot. Of course you also find stuff in Williamsburg, NY.
Of the colonial taverns I like Christina Campbell’s the best – specializes in seafood. On a long weekend you may have a problem getting a reservation at the last minute. Shields has also change a little bit lately. They’ve uncovered several examples of coffeehouses from the 18th cent. and have changed Shields to that sort of venue. It’s a bit more causal than it was, I think. I’ve not been there yet.
Also feel free to email me and let me know if there are specific types of cuisine you are looking for.
twokeltoi "at" msn "dot" com