Home › Forums › Lunch & Dinner Forums › Pizza › Where is the best pizza in New York City? › RE: Where is the best pizza in New York City? June 20, 2006 at 8:22 am #2460725 Oneiron339Member Totonno’s won the best of NY a few years running. In Brooklyn, off of Flatbush – can’t remember the street. Great pizza from a early 1900 brick oven.