Here is one that I would like to suggest..
Pizza Pasta Grill
The main difference between the two locations is that the allisonville road location has an option of a "Wood Fired" Oven as well as conventionally baked.
The Lasagna is also VERY Good.
I do not live in Indy but travel there often and this one is my Favorite.
My Favorite creation there is,
Thin crust with Goat Cheese, Mozzarella, White Cheddar, Sausage and Red Onions.
ps, I also second the "Bazbeaux" recommendations.
JW in Illinois