My wife is a devotee of SJ’s and buys them in the round "bulk" container from the store. I will occasionally down one, but recently the quality of these dog treats is narrowing to the point where some are drippingly greasy and inedible, even for SJ’s. Sometimes they are tight and snappy (as they used to advertise) but she is also a big Mt Dew drinker so maybe you have something there. Great for you Atkins people, I suppose, but I think they are (50% of the time) lousy. I’ll go for SJ Jerky if given the option. What I hate is the round white hard little nuggets conatined therein. I think of them as the express train to arterial blockage, but I am not a physiology student.