Home › Forums › Miscellaneous Forums › Miscellaneous – Food Related › Pop Tarts – Toasted or Not? › RE: Pop Tarts – Toasted or Not? July 18, 2005 at 5:34 pm #2217421 TxConnieMember I like the brown sugar cinnamon or the fruit flavored, non-frosted. Toasted. The plain ones- with butter. Going to have to try them frozen. Of course, I only eat them about once a year.