I second Al’s recommendation about the Chicken Place. Their fried chicken is hard to beat.
However, you might also consider the Schnitzelbank Restaraunt, about a mile south of the courthouse in downtown Jasper. Jasper and French Lick are not too many miles apart. If you like German food, this place is for you. They are a little pricy, but they make up for it in the quantity they bring to your table. A very high-quality restaurant that I can thoroughly recommend.