Probably late for the OP, but..
I will definitely second both the Pizza City comment. We happened to be looking for a place to eat after the train ride, and were all smorgasbord-ed out
Pizza City is just a regular joint. Nothing fancy at all, as far as the interior, even a touch run down. But they focus on the food, and it shows. The place is popular with the working guys – power crew, construction guys, etc, always a good sign. But there were more than a few guys in suits coming in too.
I had both the thin NY style pizza as well as the Sicilian thick crust and they were both excellent….. certainly better than what we have down in the Richmond area.
We also liked the ice cream place across the street.