My brother has a summer home in Williams Bay, so I gave him a call. Tsores’s suggestion is absolutely correct. Calamari is the best restaurant in Williams Bay. However, my brother suggested the following as better choices for fine dining:

1. Geneva Inn http://www.genevainn.com
2. French Country Inn http://www.kirschs.com
3. The Grand Geneva, which has three restaurants http://www.grandgeneva.com/dining/dining.asp

Enjoy.

CSD