This is much more a question than a recommendation. A few years back we had dinner at an old fashioned supper club/steak&seafood place in Menasha where my inlaws had gone on Sundays in the late 1960’s. I think it was a person’s first name, like "Arthur’s" or "Johnny’s" or some such but I can’t recall. A look at the Menasha Yellow Pages didn’t bring back any ideas. Anyway, it was very good and they had the traditional relish bar.