Unless he has a very active fan base of young girls, I predict that Jason Castro will get the boot tonight. Or, possibly Brook.
Jason’s laid-back style and lack of power to his voice made his performance last night into an embarrassment. "Broadway" songs are just not meant to be performed in the style that Jason used last night. Brook was better, but still, her performance was not top-notch–unlike Syesha, and both Davids.
As to Carly–I did not like her performance last night, but I am probably in the minority with that opinion.