Sugar Cream Pie

Cream, butter, and sugar are the essential ingredients of sugar cream pie, also known as Hoosier pie because so much of it is eaten in Indiana. A favorite of the Amish who settled in Indiana, it is a product of scarcity: no fruits are required and even eggs are not needed (although they may be added) to create the characteristic fragile jiggle by which the pie is known. Farmland bec fins like sugar pie best in the spring when Jersey cows are on new, green grass and their milk is especially rich. Brown sugar or maple syrup frequently is used, vanilla extract will flavor it, and a dusting of nutmeg is common, but any further customization goes against the pie’s elemental nature.

Restaurants With This Dish

MCL Cafeteria


Jonathan Byrd’s Cafeteria - Fried Chicken
Jonathan Byrd’s Cafeteria
Crisp-fried tenderloin, topped with tomato, onion, and lettuce, extends far beyond the burger bun that holds it
Nick’s Kitchen | Indiana Tenderloins and Sugar Cream Pie


Le P’tit Stop | Poutine & Boeuf Burgers in a Quebec Snack Bar


Nick’s Country Café



What do you think of Sugar Cream Pie?

Latest Articles & Guides

Roadfood Adventures: Covington to Mammoth Cave National Park, Kentucky

Covington to Mammoth Cave National Park, Kentucky Roadfood Adventures are not just quests...

Where to Eat Breakfast in Pittsburgh | Roadfood Bests

Breakfast in Pittsburgh is especially wonderful It is one of the nation's great breakfast...

Multi-meat BBQ meal
Road Trip: Phoenix to the Grand Canyon | Roadfood Bests

Arizona Road Trip! This three day Roadfood Adventure from Phoenix to the Grand Canyon,...

Roadfood Adventures: Scottsdale to Bisbee, Arizona

Scottsdale to Bisbee, Arizona Roadfood Adventures are not just quests for great food...

Seattle’s Best Hidden Gem Restaurants | Roadfood Bests

Maybe because it is such a coffee Mecca, Seattle also happens to be one of the nation's best...

Roadfood Adventures: Winter Park to Miami, Florida

From Orlando and Winter Park down the east coast of Florida to Miami is a journey of...


Connect with us #Roadfood