Shoofly Pie

There are two basic forms of shoofly pie: wet-bottom, which is a huge-flavored, ooey-gooey confection as sweet as any pecan pie, and dry-bottom, which is more like coffee cake. A simple mix of molasses, sugar, and crumbs, it is a legacy of Amish cooks for whom electric-powered refrigerators are anathema. The logical explanation for it name is that that once it is baked, a shoofly pie must be set out to cool. Loaded with molasses and brown sugar, it is fly bait supreme. Somebody needs to shoo them away.

Restaurants With This Dish

Kielbasa soup with tortellini & greens
Dutch Kitchen

FRACKVILLE, PA

Pappy’s Orchard & Lisa’s Kitchen

COOPERSBURG, PA

Sweet crumbs tumble from the top crust of a dark, molasses-sweet wedge of pie
Miller’s Bread Basket

BLACKVILLE, SC

Shoofly Pie Recipes

Shoo Fly Cake

Discuss

What do you think of Shoofly Pie?

Latest Articles & Guides

Top 12 favorite Ice Cream Scoops

WITH THE EXCEPTION of the hot dog bun, there has never been an edible invention as...

Lobster roll
6 best restaurants in New England

Looking for some stops along your Road trip  Check out our picks for the 6 best restaurants...

Clam Shack - Lobster Roll
14 Best Lobster Rolls in New England

Bad lobster rolls are easy to come by  We've done the research and have found the best...

Red Rocks
Best Affordable Eats Along Sedona’s Red Rock Drive

Scenic Driving and Good Eating Rising an average of an inch every 60 to 80 years, the...

Road trip | Seattle to Yakima Washington

Road Trip Overview A road trip over the Cascades through Snoqualmie Pass leads not only to a...

America’s Byways: Road trip through the Florida Keys

Road trip through the Florida Keys Surrounded by the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico...

×

Connect with us #Roadfood