Miss Monticello Diner - Monticello, NY

This diner lover's delight offers a full roster of standards ranging from old-fashioned Americana – meat loaf, hot hamburgers, omelets of all kinds – to such Grecian fundamentals as gyros and spinach pie. In addition to normal sandwiches, the menu lists hot pitas, wraps, and triple-deckers.

80% Approval Rating (5 votes)

Overall: Worth planning a day around

Must Eats

Gyro ($6.00)

Cheesecake ($2.00)

Omelet ($5.00)

Written Reviews

Michael Stern

" If diners make you happy, you'll like to pull off Route 17 in New York and stop for a meal at the Miss Monticello. It is a mid-century classic with paper placemats that have advertising for local businesses (including an emu ranch and an equipment rental company ..." [Read More].

Logbooks

9/27/2003 - Michael Stern, $7

Map & Directions

199 Broadway, Monticello, NY
845-791-8934

Hours & Policies

Seasons:	Open Year Round
Meals Served:	Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
Operational Hours:	Always Call Ahead!
Credit Cards Accepted:	Yes
Alcohol Served:	Yes
Outdoor Seating:	No
Reservations Accepted:	No
Delivery Available:	No
Takeout Counters:	No

"The Miss Monticello is not a gourmet destination, but it's good to know about if you are traveling along Route 17 with an appetite, especially at an odd hour."
Michael Stern

"The traditional Greek-diner gyro: a handful!"
Michael Stern

"Aqua blue and salmon pink: the livery of so many mid-century American hash houses"
Michael Stern

"That's a double order of bacon adjoining the Swiss and tomato omelet."
Michael Stern